darthnoir
|
Frog FF minisGreetings All,
Being careful to avoid any IP issues here...
I would be very eager to get a hold of a team of upright walking, human sized, fantasy football frogs.
3 positions would be the minimum (4 if anyone else like my wacky idea):
Receivers
Attackers
Defenders
And, for added flavor, a large sized Bull Frog "big guy" (am I violating IP there?)
To be honest, I could go for either the comical Wind in the Willows looking frogs or the more serious brutal looking frogs. I suspect most people would prefer a serious look (but I'd be happy to be proven wrong).
Anyone else interested?
|
fatgoblin
|
That would be great I think! Here is a definite vote for cute.
I thought the same thinga few weeks ago, wanting a frog team, and was looking at conversion possibilities of the eureka frogs that I have. After looking at them carefully, it seems like a hard thing to do...
Anyway, here they are if you want a look
http://eurekamin.com.au/index.php?cPath=87_126_191&sort=3a
also chronofus has got pics of a few as yet unreleased figures here, frogs and turtles
http://www.chronofus.net/php/viewtopic.php?t=197
http://www.chronofus.net/php/viewtopic.php?t=196
Another source of frog people is the sci fi ones from team frog
http://www.teamfrog.com/fig-cc.htm
|
Chairface
|
Sweet! I love the king frog:
Frogs would make an excellent team in my opinion. Either style.
|
Xtreme
|
I thought Tom had mentioned somewhere that they were having some Frog men produced.
|
Chairface
|
Theres a pretty long list of stuff!
|
Ewan
|
Tell me about it... Getting through it though (slowly but surely)
|
Chairface
|
Slow and steady wins the race.
|
fen
|
| Ewan wrote: | Tell me about it... Getting through it though (slowly but surely) |
I hope they're going to look less outlandishly stupid then the other versions I've seen on the market. Keeping the essence of frog while also making them look lean and aerodynamic. So while you do want bodies that run into heads without necks, I'd like the heads to not be oversized.
A bit of a mix of frog and lizard really. Anything cutesie looking isn't going to get my money.
|
Norse
|
Tom will personally oversee the Frogman project I think, so I am sure the end result will be pleasing to all..
|
brownrob
|
yes, tom has always wanted to see minis for a frog team, and probably has good ideas and visions for it, so I have confidence in him ;)
|
brownrob
|
|
GalakStarscraper
|
I need to build up some capital but it is on my list.
Ith and I wrote frogs into a popular FF's game background because so many folks have said the team is a lot of fun and balanced to play (and play against).
Ideally I'd like to have 7 figures (3 Midfielders, 2 Strikers, and 2 Safeties). I currently had not planned a large Bullfrog player.
Need about $2,200 to commish those 7 figures. This will be a project I do on my own time/money and then give over to Impact!
So I need to sell some stuff on Ebay ... but it is on my list.
Galak
|
fen
|
Good good, if they match that wonderful picture in style/anatomy then they'd certainly get my money.
So maybe they shouldn't look like that! :P
|
Darkson
|
HAve to agree. Something looking similar (as close as legally possible in fact) to the classic 2nd ed Slann would interest me Ones in the same style as the ones fatgoblin posted would definetly NOT get my money. Nothing wrong with them as models, just not a style I'd want to buy.
|
Xtreme
|
I would want very slim frogs, with only a few pads on. So many dynamic poses that can be made with a frog team, i'd rather not see any just standing around.
|
Thadrin
|
If a frogman team becomes available I'll actually divert some of my money to fantasy football again...despite the huge pile of teams I still have to paint.
|
rob_alderman
|
I would like to see frog-men. More like Grandma Wendy's Slann (delete if necessary because of (c) )
If you have seen flintloque Todoroni, I would like to see simalar (to the old original ones, not the awful new ones).
|
brownrob
|
Just been painting up the mini for Snake Sanders, and instead of a Snake head he had a frog head, that would do very nicely, although snake doesnt look too agile you see what I mean!
|
GalakStarscraper
|
The CalasainImpact! commissioned a frog based team at the end of last week.
Patrick Keith who did the Beer Garden Beauty for us will be working on the figures.
This team will be added to the Elfball rules as the Calasain team.
Which will have 0-4 Hunters, 0-4 Strikers, and 0-4 Midfielders
We've commissioned the following figures for this team:
2 Hunters
1 Hunter Legend
2 Strikers
1 Striker Legend
4 Midfielders
1 Cheerleader
Elfball will not add rules for Legends ... but it will give you a distinctive figure to use to show off a player on your team that has built up some skills over time.
The Reptiliad team will also be added to the Elfball rules with the same roster and composition as the Calasain team (so the figures will share a roster).
For all of those of you who have been hoping to see these ... you'll need a heavy dose of patience. The current estimate is that we will not be able to add this team to the store until the beginning of August of next year. Our current plan is not to release the team until the entire range is done rather than to trickle them out. We have several other figures we'd like to get into the store ... so the plan is that all 11 figures will go live in August of next year.
Just wanted to give an update on this as I know some folks have been interested.
Galak
|
Chairface
|
Excellent news! I was actually thinking about doing a team out of conversions from the new Horror Clix figs, but I'll wait patiently.
|
Darkson
|
I might be interested. I'm not that keen on the Slann roster (why I can't put my finger on), but if the figs look good, I'm sure I can find a use for them.
|
Norse
|
with Patrick sculpting and Tom directing, I don't doubt the Calasain will be incredible...
I wonder if we can get the Cheerleader to have large breasts though..
|
brownrob
|
wow! i had a pretty depressing day at work! but this news lifted me a bit! :D
crack the whip tom! :D
|
Bodhi
|
| Norse wrote: |
I wonder if we can get the Cheerleader to have large breasts though..  |
Guess my biology skills are not the best. I really had no idea frogs where mammals?
|
aerofool
|
I'm actually working on a frog team myself.. my first sculpted minis! I've done some conversion work before but nothing on this scale. Here is a sketch of what I have in mind for one of the catchers. If it turns out well, I'll be posting pics of the work in progress.
|
Chairface
|
| aerofool wrote: |  |
That is a fantastic concept! I love it!
|
aerofool
|
Thanks! I'm kinda concearned how the ball-tongue is going to work out. I may be making it a separate bit for the tongue/lower jaw for possibly getting it casted. But that won't be considered until I see the final product.
|
Joemanji
|
| Darkson wrote: | | I might be interested. I'm not that keen on the Slann roster (why I can't put my finger on).. | The lineman are not worth 70K.
Looking forward to the figs though. Glad a good sculptor has been attached, and that a whole team has been commissioned.
|
GalakStarscraper
|
| Joemanji wrote: | | Darkson wrote: | | I might be interested. I'm not that keen on the Slann roster (why I can't put my finger on).. | The lineman are not worth 70K. | I think I'd argue with you on that. I honestly think if the lineman were 60k ... the team would be too good.
Galak
|
GalakStarscraper
|
JJ has said there might be a real chance at bringing the Slann back in 2008 or 2009.
After talking to some of my FF friends I have decided to put the frogman project on hold until we see if Grandma Wendy is serious.
There is a very real chance if we do the figs that Grandma Wendy would nix the project due to the appearance that I pushed the team to just make money. That would be a disservice to the FF community which is not what Impact! is about.
So I'll wait. If it becomes clear that it is not going to happen ... we'll bring this project back to life.
Galak
|
Babs
|
Eureka FrogsI can speak personally that the Eureka frogs are about the right scale - and with some minor sculpting would easily make great FF players.
I have several myself. Eureka are also a really reliable company to deal with.
|
Illustranger
|
Id seen greens of a group of frog spearmen wich were imho the best Id seen for converting to a sports team (FF or my own game.) but I dont think they're for sale.
also msb toys has I believe 3 or 4 oriental frog demons wich would be nice FF miniatures when converted, probably champions tough.
|
Chairface
|
Re: Eureka Frogs | Babs wrote: | Eureka are also a really reliable company to deal with.
 |
I can second that. Great folks to do business with. The Pax Limpopo line is truly enjoyable.
|
brownrob
|
| GalakStarscraper wrote: | JJ has said there might be a real chance at bringing the Slann back in 2008 or 2009.
After talking to some of my FF friends I have decided to put the frogman project on hold until we see if Grandma Wendy is serious.
There is a very real chance if we do the figs that Grandma Wendy would nix the project due to the appearance that I pushed the team to just make money. That would be a disservice to the FF community which is not what Impact! is about.
So I'll wait. If it becomes clear that it is not going to happen ... we'll bring this project back to life.
Galak |
Waiting for an inept company like Grandma Wendy to decide to do something, when they already "allegedly" have greens for a new Dwarf team, yet dont bother casting them...
Though if Grandma Wendy decide to make a slann team, Im sure the Impact funds could be used to make something esle that will be great
How long do you think you will likely have to wait?
|
GalakStarscraper
|
| brownrob wrote: | | How long do you think you will likely have to wait? | The million dollar question. Its something I really need to kick around more in my own head.
I guess it comes down to if it appears that Grandma Wendy is going to seriously re-release a new boxed set of fantasy football. If I see that in motion next year ... I'm willing to wait. If not ... we'll go ahead with this project. The goal here like I said is not to stomp on Grandma Wendy's feet and have them not go through with making the Slann part of the rules because of what Impact! does.
Next rules review ... I might seriously quiz JJ on the Slann and see what comes of it. I'd honestly rather see Grandma Wendy grab this one and run with it and as long as strong hope exists ... I don't want to be the one that stomps it out. At the latest the 2008 Rules Review would give me my answer ... but I'm hoping to form an opinion long before then. Anyway ... I made a list a couple nights back of Impact! projects we'd like to go forward with and it adds up to over 5500 GBP ($10000) easily. So there is plenty of stuff to look at for partner pet projects for Impact! My first one is going to be to work with Fen and get something cool to the market to replace my "sadness" over delaying the Calasain project.
Galak
|
brownrob
|
Dice?
|
Chairface
|
| brownrob wrote: | Dice?  |
|
Darkson
|
For those that like the real frog looking range (yuck!), couple of potential off-field models:
|
axiom
|
Hi Galak - any news on the frogmen team? I've actually come to this forum simply by doing a google search as I was looking for a slann-style FF team. I'd definitely be keen if the project gets revitalised!
|
GalakStarscraper
|
| axiom wrote: | | Hi Galak - any news on the frogmen team? I've actually come to this forum simply by doing a google search as I was looking for a slann-style FF team. I'd definitely be keen if the project gets revitalised! |
To be honest we are waiting to see what happens with the rules of the game. I would never want anything Impact! did to actually damage the process of the game. So we wait and see what happens with upcoming reviews of the rules so that I see if there is a conflict.
Bottom line ... nothing is being done on this front now. We are working on a limited edition fantasy football frog miniature that Impact! was commissioned to make for an upcoming tournament which we will have a few extra copies to sell ... but nothing beyond this.
Galak
|
GalakStarscraper
|
I'll be honest .... I built a team using either of these formulas and thought it looked pretty good:
new Kroot, Skink Champions, Chameleon Blowgun, and Kroxigor
or
Reptiliad Hunter, Striker, and Midfielder with Terrorpin
Galak
|
axiom
|
| GalakStarscraper wrote: | | Bottom line ... nothing is being done on this front now. We are working on a limited edition fantasy football frog miniature that Impact! was commissioned to make for an upcoming tournament which we will have a few extra copies to sell ... but nothing beyond this. |
That's fair enough! I look forward to the limited figure when it arrives in the meantime.
|
DG_Slider
|
| fen wrote: | Good good, if they match that wonderful picture in style/anatomy then they'd certainly get my money.
So maybe they shouldn't look like that! :P |
I second that. I would love a $.... err Frog team. Especially if it resembles the picture. I hated that a mini line like those were never released.
|
Boromir_and_kermit
|
I'm probably just being too curious for my own good, but with the transferrance of the Specialist Games Forum and mention of a decision on a rules meet next month, has the concept of a Frog team 'caught any more flies' so to say???
What I'm asking is... is this still a possibility/something you want to do/pursue Tom?
Cheers,
Ben.
(Thanks for sending out the Siringit team out so quickly, brilliant models!)
PS. I have a team of converted Eureka frogs, but although as cool as they are, against the other stuff - Siringit, Pharohs etc... they are too cartoony)
|
aerofool
|
| Boromir_and_kermit wrote: | I'm probably just being too curious for my own good, but with the transferrance of the Specialist Games Forum and mention of a decision on a rules meet next month, has the concept of a Frog team 'caught any more flies' so to say???
What I'm asking is... is this still a possibility/something you want to do/pursue Tom?
|
The 2008 Rules Review is complete and it looks like our fave amphibians are endorsed, yet still not supported with miniatures by the noted "old lady".
Would I be correct to believe that many involved in the FF community will be looking to impact! to bring these guys to the forefront?
Does any of this change the outlook and scheduling of getting these guys made, or is it still a "not at this time" plan?
|
Norse
|
Impact! will not be making any frogman like minis in the foreseeable future.
We do, however, have a caster working on some amphibious conversion sprues (heads, hands etc) for people to use..
|
GalakStarscraper
|
| Norse wrote: | Impact! will not be making any frogman like minis in the foreseeable future.
We do, however, have a caster working on some amphibious conversion sprues (heads, hands etc) for people to use..  |
It has to do with a line that we are trying to be respective of JJ and G-W at the same time.
I personally promised JJ that I would not make Frog miniatures and while I may have downside characteristics ... I'm a man of my word.
However ... to help sell Kroot sprues in the store ... we are planning on supplementing BBFigs with sprues that will help the Kroot sell.
Galak
|
Dark Lord
|
Tom,
I'm not one to encourage a man to break his word but wasn't your promise to JJ based upon some sort of action to be taken by Grandma Wendy in the foreseeable future?
Maybe I am mistaken but I was under the impression that you weren't going to do it because they were...or because they were back to the fish hook line about a new box set...or some such thing.
I understand where you're coming from on this one and I respect it.
but at the same time, how long are you going to let Grandma Wendy dictate Impact's strategy?
I don't mean that to sound harsh, and I know there is reason to fear Grandma Wendy's wrath, but at the same time, they aren't exactly the 800 lb gorilla they once were...they are barely a mad monkey. With the year they have had, and with all of their upper management rearrangement, they are hardly in the position to sue somebody over a game they don't even support. This is a product that you know would be a seller, and last I heard you guys could use some cash.
All I'm saying is maybe you should check your memory and see if JJ and Grandma Wendy are holding up their end of the bargain?
If they are not, they you could make this product without breaking your word.
Just my 2 cents.
|
GalakStarscraper
|
I understand your points DL ... but since you don't do tournaments ... you might not be aware of new happenings.
I've personally campaigned with Jervis for 5 years to have the Slann added to B.lood B.owl.
And now they are official in every aspect except miniatures and being in the LRB.
Now while that sounds like a big deal I admit. But to me in the end ... Jervis upheld his end of the bargin.
When the NAF called him and asked if he considered the Slann official ... he said yes.
As a result of that in September the NAF started to allow tournaments to have the Slann compete in them. And in just 7 weeks ... its spreading like wildfire.
Already 3 of the official G-W majors are going to allow Slann to compete in them in 2009 ... (Chaos Cup, Dungeonbowl, and the Spike!). The 5th NAF Major (CanCon) is allowing them next year as well. The only NAF Major that has not yet agreed to allow them in is the B.lood B.owl in the UK and Darkson was going to make a pitch to them that the other 4 NAF Majors were allowing the team in.
So while I fully agree with you that the miniatures from them are not forth coming. Jervis in my mind upheld his end of the bargin as with one phone call to the NAF ... he has pretty much guaranteed that the vast majority of tournament (and as a result that will spread the word back to most leagues in the world) will have the Slann in them.
So in my mind ... I would be a lesser man if I made a full frog team after Jervis made my dream of 5 years a reality. As you have frequently said ... B-B is a game owned by the players now ... so what JJ's bosses do about the Slann was never really part of the deal. But with that call JJ assured that the players had a ball they could run with and make the team as official as anything that JJ's bosses allowed to be "official". And since the G-W tournament organizers are not really worrying about what JJ's bosses are saying either ... to my mind ... I don't feel like the bargin was not upheld on JJ's end.
Galak
|
Dark Lord
|
That's cool, and I respect that. I really do.
| GalakStarscraper wrote: | | So in my mind ... I would be a lesser man if I made a full frog team after Jervis made my dream of 5 years a reality. |
But you should know it's statement's like this that drive me crazy. (Not just from you...but from the acolytes of Grandma Wendy as a whole. WHAT exactly did JJ do besides delegate unpaid work to you and a few other people and then handcuff you when you tried to do it correctly?
He answered the phone and said, "Sure." Why are people even still calling him for official rulings?!
If bl00d b0wl is "our" game then why worry about what some bonkers old twit who doesn't even play the game considers official?
The deification of Jervis Johnson is a mystery to me.
I love you to death, Tom and I love Elfball...but you'll never dictate my league or tournament rules. Sorry.
|
brownrob
|
Yeah, If i ever win the lottery (I need to start entering!) then one of the first things Ill do, besides look after the family and essentials, is commission my own frog team, then spares could be sold off cheaply to anyone who would have been interested!
|
aerofool
|
OK, let me get this straight, Slann are official to use in 4 of the 5 (will prolly soon be all 5) major NAF tourneys. Unless I go with the really cartoonish frogs, I'm expected to convert Kroot sprues?
I think brownrob may be onto something here. Maybe a group of interested people need to get together and commission a frog team. Just 6 people, each with enough cash to get one model sculpted and cast should be enough to put together a team. It can be done independently of Tom, impact!, JJ and Grandma Wendy.
I don't want to force anyone, especially Tom, to go against his word no matter how jipped I feel on the whole "endorsed but not supported" issue.
|
Dark Lord
|
It amazes me how many times Grandma Wendy passes up the chance to make money from Bl00d B0wl.
It probably will need to be a grass roots sort of thing. Even if Grandma Wendy did it you'd only end up with a $50 box set of 12 minis for an incomplete team and need to buy 4 other $15 blister packs to round it out.
|
GalakStarscraper
|
| aerofool wrote: | | I'm expected to convert Kroot sprues? | Yes that and that is what BBFigs.com is paying to have made. A conversion sprue that will make a Kroot base look very Slannish.
This will also make sure that a Slann team taken to an official G-W event is legal as they require the figure to be 80% G-W products.
So this will fix that issue. I think the only event that will be really picky on the 80% rule would be the B.lood B.owl in the UK. The other ones are normally happy if they can tell you started from Grandma Wendy stock.
And Dark Lord ... why I care. Look if Jervis had not agreed that he viewed the team as official ... the NAF would never have allowed them in and without that endorsement ... the team would be effectively dead. So yeah ... all he did was say "Yes" on a phone call. But he was saying "Yes" when his bosses were saying "No". That was a rebel "Yes" ... he didn't just play puppet for his bosses who I fully agree are complete idiots in my opinion (especially since I offered to have the team sculpted for them professionally and then give the greens to them with a full release of my rights to them). But its JJ's bosses I have the axe to grind with ... JJ and the G-W official tournament organizers so far have played ball completely. Be interesting to see what the B.lood B.owl organizers do.
Galak
|
Dark Lord
|
| GalakStarscraper wrote: | | And Dark Lord ... why I care. Look if Jervis had not agreed that he viewed the team as official ... the NAF would never have allowed them in and without that endorsement ... the team would be effectively dead. |
It's not really you that confuses me...it's that sort of action by the NAF. Why do they care what JJ sez? They could (and probably do) have more authority over the rules than JJ does. Or at the very least if JJ made a ruling on a rules discrepancy and the NAF made an opposite ruling on the same rule...I'd guess (in a blind poll) more people would side with the NAF's ruling, one that comes from first hand experience, over the ruling of a guy that makes arbitrary decisions while he farts in the bath tub and hasn't actually played the game in years. (Cripes the least he could do is play PBeM.)
I just am very anxious to see Bl00d B0wl out of the hands of JJ and his dark masters and into the hands of somebody competent.
| GalakStarscraper wrote: | So yeah ... all he did was say "Yes" on a phone call. But he was saying "Yes" when his bosses were saying "No". That was a rebel "Yes" ... he didn't just play puppet for his bosses who I fully agree are complete idiots in my opinion (especially since I offered to have the team sculpted for them professionally and then give the greens to them with a full release of my rights to them). But its JJ's bosses I have the axe to grind with ... JJ and the G-W official tournament organizers so far have played ball completely. Be interesting to see what the B.lood B.owl organizers do.
Galak |
Sure that's all well and good from my tiny window on the situation it seems like his bosses aren't exactly saying but rather saying, "Huh, what? Bl00d B0wl again? No, we don't care about that game, how is that new 40K Codex coming along?"
So I would really only dispute with the "rebel" title you give him.
But I will restate that I respect your decision, after all a man's word is all he has. Also, it's that sort of integrity that will make Impact succeed where Grandma Wendy fails.
I just hope you don't promise then anything else, and eventually tell them to piss off. I'd love to see what Impact could do without worrying about Grandma Wendy's over-budgeted legal eagles.
|
GalakStarscraper
|
| Dark Lord wrote: | | and hasn't actually played the game in years. | Actually in a very interesting development. Jervis came over and played in the Chaos Cup (I think you knew he was doing that).
Now I'm not claiming at all that that qualfies as serious playing the game. But he held his own okay for the event.
So it was nice to see him getting out and actually playing the game. And he was a open supporter to the Chaos Cup having the new teams next year ... so it was nice to have that validation right there with the G-W store managers present.
Also JJ does understand what happened. When the Manager made the comment at the beginning ... "well it will be nice to know that if we have any rules arguments that the ultimate source is here to answer them" ... JJ turned and pointed to me and said "no if you need the ultimate rules source he's over there"
And don't worry ... the Slann is the last deal I hope to have a hand tying agreement on.
Galak
|
Norse
|
perhaps this kind of chat would be better in PM...
|
lahatiel
|
Better? Perhaps... but far less entertaining!
|
Dark Lord
|
| Norse wrote: | perhaps this kind of chat would be better in PM...  |
Well it's probably better to stop it anyway. Tom and I both know that as he's as much of a Grandma Wendy apologist as I am a Grandma Wendy hater.
|
Darkson
|
| aerofool wrote: | | Slann are official to use in 4 of the 5 (will prolly soon be all 5) major NAF tourneys. |
Don't hold your breath.
I was the official Chief Referee for the B.llod B.owl GT this year, Lycos had many phone call/email conversations with the guy running the Events at GWHQ.
Neither of us have heard a thing since the GT - Lycos has sent more than a few emails without reply.
I'll try, and I'd guess lycos will as well, but the UK Events team hasn't shown itself to be the "easiest" people to deal with.
|
Mad Jackal
|
| Darkson wrote: | | aerofool wrote: | | Slann are official to use in 4 of the 5 (will prolly soon be all 5) major NAF tourneys. |
Don't hold your breath.
I was the official Chief Referee for the B.llod B.owl GT this year, Lycos had many phone call/email conversations with the guy running the Events at GWHQ.
Neither of us have heard a thing since the GT - Lycos has sent more than a few emails without reply.
I'll try, and I'd guess lycos will as well, but the UK Events team hasn't shown itself to be the "easiest" people to deal with. |
Hey mate. If a stand-up fellow like yourself says he's going to give something a go. That is good enough for me. If it doesn't happen I know it won't be because you sold it short. Give it your best and those guys will hang themselves if they feel they must.
thanks
|
Rabid_Bogscum
|
can I ask all you guys for your take on what Goblin Forge has come up with.. does that put them in danger of not being 'official'?
|
Norse
|
I expect Goblin Forge to get in very hot water over this...
http://www.talkbloodbowl.com/phpBB2/viewtopic.php?t=26105
|
Dark Lord
|
The Goblin Forge frogs don't look up to their usual quality IMO. They sort of lack any details and the anatomy is strange.
What does the TBB link say?
|
Norse
|
it's just GF's link to the "new stuff" - no real feedback other than that as yet..
I agree the sculpts are not up to much - still too comical for my liking, but I cannot say that on TBB without having hundreds of irate Frenchmen accusing Impact! of sour grapes or world domination..
I guess they are similar to Shadowforges "simplistic" look.. maybe painted up they would look much better..
|
lahatiel
|
It's just the Goblin Forge announcement of the figures, and then a discussion started on whether this cause any problems with Grandma Wendy over their past proclamation that they'd refuse to officially recognize the Slann roster if some other company sold a frog team.
And while granted, I've never had much interest in a Slann team to begin with, add me to the list of those unimpressed by these sculpts.
|
Dark Lord
|
I'll be curious to see if they do the one pose I have in my head. If I were ever asked to sketch them the first one I would draw would be a catcher type leaping up to catch the ball with a big webbed hand. From the looks of their gloved hands I'd say they didn't do that.
But I'm not a big fan on the Kroot either...they look like turtles and not frogs.
I'm more interested in something like this
|
SillySod
|
They look funny enough for them to be fun to use but they dont look like much fun to paint... ideally they should have all the realistic details but the overall effect should be comical (a bit like looking at a platapus). Dont think these will be replacing my kroot anytime soon
|
sebco
|
| Norse wrote: |
I agree the sculpts are not up to much - still too comical for my liking, but I cannot say that on TBB without having hundreds of irate Frenchmen accusing Impact! of sour grapes or world domination..
|
I agree too.
(about these ones... some other of their frog minis I recently saw sound better to me, especially the blizers, but I think Goblin Forge will show the pictures soon)
Concerning the "hundreds of irate frenchmen" I think you didn't really understand our (mine) opinion when we (I) wrote about it on TBB but that's not really important... I only want to tell you again it was nothing against you or Impact! I personnaly much appreciate everything you do here (I do not like your whole range of minis but appreciate how you work, your forum, your prices, etc...)
That said, about GF frogs, if your opinion about these sculpts is a shared one, other guys will tell it on TBB forums and I personnaly think it's better. ;)
By me, the main problem of this frog team isn't the sculpts quality. Having read some topics here and on TBB months ago about Impact! not producing frog minis, I fear about the slann not being officialised because of these minis. I told it to Talkarde (the new GF owner) when he showed me the minis at a french FF tournament but it was too late : he did yet launch the production of these minis. I have to tell here that, as most of french bloodbowlers, he told me he didn't know about all that (Grandma Wendy not wanting any company to produce any frog mini or they won't accept slann in LRB 6). He only saw the new team list for LRB 6 and didn't know why the other companies didn't sell them yet...
|
GalakStarscraper
|
| Rabid_Bogscum wrote: | | can I ask all you guys for your take on what Goblin Forge has come up with.. does that put them in danger of not being 'official'? | That time has past in many ways.
Once JJ told the NAF that they were official to him and then the NAF added them (today they official posted the NAF rules for tournament organizers to use the 3 new teams). So in terms of tournaments and leagues finding out about them that ball is rolling beyond anyone's ability to stop.
As for official-dom. JJ made it very clear at Chaos Cup that his bosses would not allow the 3 new teams into LRB 6.0. So I don't think there was any real chance that G-W would make the miniatures and allow the team in LRB 6.0.
====
How I see this playing out.
GoblinForge will make their team which in my opinion is just way too comical for me to use. I'd rather convert Kroot or use Reptiliads to get a "real" look to them. BBFigs.com some time next year will sell Kroot sprues and conversion pieces to allow folks to have Frog teams that can be officially used at G-W events. I don't have a problem talking about the Frog sprues BBFigs.com is working on because those sprues are being made to HELP G-W sell more product (not remove sales from them).
=====
So at the end of the day ... I think they damage GF will do is minor.
I think if they had announced this team before the BBRC Review this year or the NAF's phone call to JJ ... this could have been nightmarishly bad and I would have emailed them to say so. But timing wise ... it should be okay.
Galak
|
Norse
|
| sebco wrote: | I personnaly much appreciate everything you do here (I do not like your whole range of minis but appreciate how you work, your forum, your prices, etc...)
|
I do not like our whole range of products either.. Galak often points out that our best selling range of minis are the ones I rejected initially and he had to talk me around..
beauty is in the eye of the beholder I guess.. and I wish Talkarde success with this range and GF in general, I know him well from when he lived in Holland and I even let him beat me once .. what I would say is that I rate Sylvain Quirion as one of the top 3 fantasy football sculptors out there - I doubt these sculpts are from him though, which is a shame..
|
Mephisto
|
Don't like them either, but perhaps, I'm going to order at least one or two models if that is possible. Perhaps with a bit of greensculpt they look more fierce.
But, on the other side, I think it's great that they do such a team. Let's wait how much they'll cost.
|
GalakStarscraper
|
| sebco wrote: | He only saw the new team list for LRB 6 and didn't know why the other companies didn't sell them yet...  | I suspected if any company decided to make the figures it was going to be be one of the 3 smaller companies (GoblinForge, GreenDog, or Orc from Billbao).
I figured it was a matter of time before one of them just decided to do it ... regardless of what might happen from doing so ... I am glad to find out that he had no idea that he might be doing a "very bad" thing before he did.
Like I said if this picture was put out before about 3 weeks ago ... it would have completely screwed over the entire process horribly and I would have been the first to be emailing him and telling him that if he wanted to guarantee that he'd never sell any of them to continue on.
However ... we got lucky. The NAF made the teams officially ranked and the organizers of the Majors announced they were including the teams before he showed this players. So he didn't destroy 5 years of my work.
So we see what happens ... like I said .. the timing should be okay and should not cause much damage compared to what it could have done.
Galak
|
GalakStarscraper
|
| Norse wrote: | | I do not like our whole range of products either. | I have to confirm this.
When I show the partners the # of figures sold by model code ... Ramsay often comments .... "I cannot believe we've sold so many of XYZ model."
And there are some on our site that I think are great that sell very little. The Reptiliads being one example of this. And then others I'm amazed at how many we've sold.
Galak
|
sebco
|
Yes it's a matter of taste. Furthermore, Impact! now has a big big range of minis and some are amateur ones. It would be incredible if everybody would like your whole range of minis. I just wrote that to not seem to be a crawler.
|
Ted Striker
|
I have bred a few different frog species so I felt compelled to chime in.
The GF frogs are really far off my tastes as well. They look way to silly. Just not a fan of the one DL posted either. For my money, the Limited Impact Frogman is just spot on. I wish Tom De Wolf could make a team in that "realistic" style. It just seems that none of the frog mini's I have seen, the sculptor spent any time looking at real amphibian physiology. And that may not have been their vision. But I think it looks much better. Just MHO.
Any chance for a preview of the Kroot sprues since they are fairly central to the thread. I would love to see how they look as I'm not familiar with the Grandma Wendy base for the conversion.
I hope Galak's vision of the harm done by GF is correct. That other FF game has stagnant support now. I'd hate to see it actually move backwards.
|
Dark Lord
|
As far as the pic I posted I didn't mean something exactly like that. I would definitely want webbed hands and feet, and sleeker bodies. That one would make an okay defender or something but I don't think, he's perfect either. He just illustrated a more serious take on the model.
The Impact frog is awesome, and I would love see more in that style.
I don't really get the Kroot as substitutes tho. I mean what is so "frog" about them?
|
Darkson
|
Not that keen on the GF ones either, but then I've not liked the other "funny" models posted on various FF forums either.
|
Mephisto
|
| GalakStarscraper wrote: | | Norse wrote: | | I do not like our whole range of products either. | I have to confirm this.
When I show the partners the # of figures sold by model code ... Ramsay often comments .... "I cannot believe we've sold so many of XYZ model."
And there are some on our site that I think are great that sell very little. The Reptiliads being one example of this. And then others I'm amazed at how many we've sold.
Galak |
What is wrong with them? I have a whole team (without staff). I think the problem with the Reptiliads is:
1) They are not painted. They would gain a lot painted.
2) They are in a section, down in the site, a little bit hidden.
I think if you change that, you could improve their situation.
Another idea to give them more importance would be to do a special offer (15% off) during one week...
|
sebco
|
I agree with Mephisto concerning the Reptiliads. If I would see them painted I would maybe change my opinion about them. Recently, some Phigs' minis have been shown well painted on Impact! website and it really changed my opinion about them.
Moreover, they have, by me, some minor flaws which can put some potential customers (for example : me ) out of buying them :
-their metal sticked base
-their eccentric poses : some of these poses are well done according to me but there's IMHO a lack of more classical poses for these minis so it's difficult to have a complete team of reptiliads easy to use for FF.
That said, Reptiliads are in the Side Impact Minis section. So this is only a bonus. I don't mind about some Side Impact Minis not suiting to me, that doesn't change my great opinion about Impact! minis.
|
Norse
|
my bad.. I told Tom I would paint the team and after doing the coach, apo and cheerleaders, I gave up...
nothing to do with the minis themselves (I think they are great scuplts although I agree some of the poses are not ideal for the kind of games we play) just that like many painters, I lose interest in a project quite quickly.. I have probably started dozens of teams and only ever finished a handful..
so if anyone wants to volunteer to paint up the team (keep the fuscia and blue colour scheme though) I don't think Tom would object in the slightest...
R
|
GalakStarscraper
|
| Norse wrote: | so if anyone wants to volunteer to paint up the team (keep the fuscia and blue colour scheme though) I don't think Tom would object in the slightest...
R | I paid to have the team painted and just received it back very recently. Just need to get it photographed and posted.
Galak
|
brownrob
|
| Norse wrote: | I have probably started dozens of teams and only ever finished a handful..
|
So true!
I still havent finished my Gnolls, and Ill probably buy more minis before i pick up a brush to paint my own!
I really should try to downsize my collection though
|
Norse
|
| GalakStarscraper wrote: | | Norse wrote: | so if anyone wants to volunteer to paint up the team (keep the fuscia and blue colour scheme though) I don't think Tom would object in the slightest...
R | I paid to have the team painted and just received it back very recently. Just need to get it photographed and posted.
Galak |
great news!
|
Dark Lord
|
I'll have the multi-part humans done soon. And I really believe they have more potential than Tom estimates.
They were a lot of fun to assemble, and they are SOOOOOOO conversion friendly!
It would make my year to see Impact release more mutant parts for them.
Animal heads (including frogs) could be part of the sprue(s).
|
Mephisto
|
| Norse wrote: | | GalakStarscraper wrote: | | Norse wrote: | so if anyone wants to volunteer to paint up the team (keep the fuscia and blue colour scheme though) I don't think Tom would object in the slightest...
R | I paid to have the team painted and just received it back very recently. Just need to get it photographed and posted.
Galak |
great news!  |
Why don't you contact Dani Sadgar? He would do a great job!
|
Thom
|
| Mephisto wrote: | What is wrong with them? I have a whole team (without staff). I think the problem with the Reptiliads is:
1) They are not painted. They would gain a lot painted.
2) They are in a section, down in the site, a little bit hidden.
I think if you change that, you could improve their situation.
Another idea to give them more importance would be to do a special offer (15% off) during one week... |
I couldn't agree more, they need to be painted and listed as a team with the other teams in the "ELFBALL TEAM MINIATURES" section rather than in the "SIDE IMPACT MINIS" section.
| Dark Lord wrote: | It would make my year to see Impact release more mutant parts for them.
Animal heads (including frogs) could be part of the sprue(s). |
Weapons sprues should be added to that list please! (Along with more torso and head sprues with a varitey of helmet styles!) Same for the Heresy Ogre, other torso and leg options for them would help a lot to increase potential variations. . .
|
brownrob
|
| Dark Lord wrote: |
It would make my year to see Impact release more mutant parts for them.
Animal heads (including frogs) could be part of the sprue(s). |
Hmmm yeah good idea!!
But I cant see it happening to be honest
Perhaps a selection of reptilian heads?
|
lahatiel
|
| Dark Lord wrote: | I'll have the multi-part humans done soon. And I really believe they have more potential than Tom estimates.
They were a lot of fun to assemble, and they are SOOOOOOO conversion friendly!
It would make my year to see Impact release more mutant parts for them.
Animal heads (including frogs) could be part of the sprue(s). |
Ooh, nice... I'm looking forward to seeing what someone else has done with them! Truth be told, one of the reasons why I didn't make more of an effort to get back to painting mine was that, in the end, I'm not sure how happy I am with some of my conversions -- I think I could do a much better job, knowing what I know now. In fact, I've even had the odd thought here and there of perhaps selling them off and then getting a new team's worth and starting over... although who knows how long it would be before that ever happened, if I decided to go that route.
Plus, I'd have to put together a few more before I sold them, anyway -- Elfball players would probably be fine with the 12 I have made already, but I'm guessing I could probably expand my potential market if I added another, oh, say about 4 or so!
|
Boromir_and_kermit
|
I have 8 pet frogs and have had frogs around all my life.
The Goblin forge ones are laughable.
Yes I know that I have converted Eureka frogs that are comical. But at least those are consistent in their style. The Goblin forge ones are all over the place. They are atrocious.
I have no idea how you would do frogs from Kroot, but would love to see what people have done/intend to do (photos help)
To be honest, the limited edition Frogman that you guys have already done is outstanding, both in proportions/appearance. A whole team of them would have been bloody brilliant and would have sold through the roof no doubt.
I respect the decision not to make a whole team, but am bitterly, bitterly disappointed that you won't.
I know you are releasing sprues to help do Kroot ones, but really... as good as I'm sure they will be, they will pale in comparision to what a whole team would have looked like.
Oh well.
Ben.
PS. I agree that the Reptiliads should be moved to the Impact team area and the painted team that you just got done Tom will surely boost sales! Good luck!
|
SillySod
|
| Dark Lord wrote: | | I don't really get the Kroot as substitutes tho. I mean what is so "frog" about them? |
Its the leg/torso proportions. Also while their feet arent webbed they do look like they have evolved only a short distance from something swiming in a pond.
|
Boromir_and_kermit
|
Does anyone have any photos of a Kroot-frog conversion?
Cheers,
Ben.
|
|
|